Published in The Times dated August 6, 2001

Congressional investigators have recently released a scathing report charging that within the last two years more than 30 percent of the nation’s nursing homes – about 5,285 facilities – were cited by state inspectors for at least one abuse violation that had the potential to cause harm.

These facilities were cited for almost 9,000 violations during the two-year congressional study, the report said.

Citing information gleaned from a sampling of state inspection reports or formal complaints, the 15-page report released last week at a hearing called by Henry Waxman (D-Calif), Minority Chairman of the House Committee of Government Reform, found that in more than 1,600 nursing facilities, approximately one out of every 10, the abuse violations were serious enough to cause significant harm to residents or to place them in immediate jeopardy of death or serious injury.

Abused residents were punched, choked or kicked by staff members or other residents, the report said, stating that the attacks frequently caused serious injuries such as fractured bones and lacerations.  In other instances, residents were being groped or sexually molested.

Although the report, “Abuse of Residents is a Major Problem in U.S. Nursing Homes,” prepared by Minority Staff of the Committee’s Special Investigation Division, found that the percentage of nursing facilities with abuse violations is increasing, it noted that the reasons for this increase are unclear.

In his opening remarks, Waxman stated that it had been unwise for Congress to repeal the Boren Amendment in 1997, a federal law which mandated that states provide nursing facilities with adequate funding to operate.  Because of this, he said, Medicaid funding for nursing facility care has not kept pace with the rising costs of providing care.

Waxman’s legislative prescription for attacking the growing abuse in the nation’s nursing facilities is to introduce a legislative proposal that would reestablish the abolished Boren Amendment, mandating minimum nurse staffing requirements, imposing tougher regulatory sanctions on poorly performing facilities, and instituting criminal background checks for nursing facility employees, or increasing internet disclosures on nursing facility care.

What’s playing out in Rhode Island?

According to Wayne Farrington, Chief of Facilities Regulation at the state’s Department of Health, the reporting of Rhode Island abuse complaints has risen by 10 percent.  The statewide increase in reports of abuse, neglect and mistreatment probably mirrors the tragic national problem, he tells All About Seniors, but is smaller because the Rhode Island 1987 statute has made it a misdemeanor for health care professionals or public safety officials not to report suspected abuse, neglect, mistreatment.  The size of the national increase is partially due to abuse reporting being a new requirement in some states.  Farrington added. 

Farrington states that the biggest factor that increases the number of reported calls of abuse, neglect and mistreatment is the severe statewide staffing shortage in Rhode Island’s nursing facilities.

“Overworked staff may become short tempered and this can result in abuse.  Not enough staff in the facility may also result in resident’s needs not being met,” he added.

Administrator Hugh Hall, of Cherry Hill Manor, also feels that the state’s critical staffing crisis contributes to the possibility of increased abuse and that crisis also affects the quality of care provided in the state’s 104 nursing facilities.

“Today’s nursing facility employees are underpaid, overworked creating an environment in which even the best employee may falter,” Hall said.

The administrator urges the General Assembly to increase Medicaid payments to more adequately cover the nursing facility’s actual cost of care, allowing for greater increases in direct care provider salaries.

“While last year’s average cost of care in a Rhode Island facility was $140 per day the state’s Medicaid program only reimbursed facilities $116 for the care provided, creating a serious shortage of funds in many facilities, Hall added.

“There are not enough certified nursing assistants in the system to deliver the care,” Hall said noting that opportunities must be created and a fair wage paid to attract people into this profession.

Meanwhile, Hall believes that the overwhelming majority of nursing facilities in Rhode Island provide quality care.  These facilities do criminal background checks and provide staff training.  They educate their staff about the facility’s expectation on quality patient care, he said.

Hall says facilities that have on going problems with abuse should be prosecuted to “the fullest extent of the law.”

Although Roberta Hawkins, the state’s Long-Term Care Ombudsman and Executive Director of the Alliance for Better Long-Term Care sides with Farrington and Hall about the critical need to directly confront the adverse impact of the staffing shortage in facilities, “it’s not to excuse to provide bad care,” she says.  “If facilities can’t care for residents then they should not admit them.”

A mandated continuing education program for both professional nurses and certified nursing assistants can be an effective strategy for reducing the incidence of abuse while enabling the better trained worker to care for more medically complex residents.

Additionally, Hawkins and long-term care providers are pushing for more state and federal Medicaid dollars to be allocated to provide a living wage for direct care workers.

Although lawmakers this year gave a small increase, “it’s not what was needed but it’s a start,” she acknowledges.

A divided Congress and a conservative Bush White House may well keep Waxman’s legislative proposal that addresses the problem of rising abuse in the nation’s more than 17,000 nursing facilities from every being enabled.

So, change must begin in the Ocean State.

When the Rhode Island General Assembly comes back into session next year, it becomes critical that the serious direct care staffing shortage in Rhode Island’s nursing facilities become a top legislative priority.

As the Republican and Democratic Gubernatorial candidates gear up their political campaigns and dream of becoming the state’s top elected policy official, they might well consider taking up the just cause of improving the care provided in the state’s nursing facilities.

Lawmakers can gubernatorial candidates can ill afford to ignore this key policy issue, one that puts the state’s 10,000 frail nursing facility residents in continued jeopardy of abuse, neglect or mistreatment.

On a political note, hundred of thousands of families and friends of these residents, who are voters, are watching.